One of the most difficult things for me to do is tell someone less-than-pleasant news. (I mean, consider how I worded that: “less-than-pleasant news.” I can’t even write anything other than a euphemism.) And, when it’s an experience I have never had, neither from the giving nor receiving standpoint, I am absolutely agonized. So, what happened?
Last night, during a pretty decent conversation with the guy I’ve been seeing, I let him know how I have been feeling, or rather, not been feeling, about our relationship. I hadn’t planned on saying anything last night; I wasn’t even certain I would say anything at all, in the near-term at least. But I had been planning what I would say whenever the time came that I mustered up the guts to follow through with it.
I had just gotten out of a movie around 5:45pm and was headed home to get ready to go out with some friends who wanted to “do something” for my birthday, which was Friday. John had called and left a voice mail, so I rang him back. We talked the entire drive home and continued to do so as I got ready to go out. The conversation really was good: he told me about a funny situation with a woman at work who was having a relationship with him that he was unaware of (she had “broken up” with him on the phone that morning - quite a funny story) and then we meandered into talking about our relationship by way of him asking me essentially if I would be his girlfriend. This latter portion of the conversation, too, was good, though I played coy quite a bit because I didn’t know how to answer him.
[On the one hand, I really do enjoy hanging out with him: seeing a movie, sharing a good conversation, and just plain having someone around who seems to like me for who I am. But on the other hand, I have been having trouble feeling anything romantic.]
In his silly-yet-serious tone, he asked me for one reason I shouldn’t be with him and three that I should. I hesitantly gave him my responses: I should not be with you because of the problems you have (e.g., drinking heavily); I should be with you because you sincerely like me for who I am, you’re a very caring person, and you’re a very sensitive person. I meant every last word. He is a good guy on all those counts. We chatted some more, and I could tell - just like I’ve noticed over the last couple of weeks - that he is far more into me than I feel I am with him. For instance, he told me that he feels best when he is around me; that he looks forward to seeing me when he never feels that way about anyone else.
I want to be into him. I feel I have tried to be into him. But our relationship has basically flip-flopped. In November and December, I was far more into him than I thought he was with me. After Christmas, that all changed. And, I know why…
The Sunday after Christmas we were hanging out at his place and he was relying heavily on beer. He drank a lot. I mean, he finished off nearly 18 beers all on his own (over the course of 10 hours or so, but still). He was shitfaced by the time I left (my car was elsewhere so I had to rely on carpooling back to my vehicle, so it’s not like I could easily just walk out). Now, when he is drunk, he’s just drunk: not violent, not abusive, just inebriated. But, it was a side of him I didn’t want to see but one that I potentially needed to see sooner rather than later. I was embarrassed to be seen with him. He was utterly unattractive to me in those hours. Later that Monday I could tell he was trying to pretend like the night before hadn’t happened; he even asked me to “try to look past this.” And I wanted to try. But something in my voice over the next week told him I was bothered…
That’s when he called me out on it about a week later and after several phone conversations. He told me that the way I was responding to him had an edge in it that made him feel like I had a problem - ever since “that night.” I was thrown off guard, but I was as honest as I could make myself be while trying to maintain the relationship. I told him that I was bothered by his drinking that night and that if I had an edge in my voice since then it was probably because of that; that, it is important to me that he can be around me without drinking so much; that what I saw of him that night was unattractive - not so much physically as otherwise. I could tell he was hurt by what I had to say but he took it as well as could be expected, I suppose. The call ended sort of abruptly and for about three days, I wondered where we stood.
Being the understanding (perhaps naive in your view) person, I knew that the week this all happened was a rough one for him: school (he is a high-school teacher) was just going back into session after the holidays and the school he works at has significant behavioral issues. And, John is tormented by the strain/stress of working there, so he has to pull back from other things in order to make it through the day/week/month. And I get that. But still, he didn’t call… he didn’t email… nothing. That’s when I decided to make the first move. I called him three days later; by week’s end, we were talking again as if nothing had ever happened.
And that is when the dynamics of our relationship had flipped: I still had a problem with “that night” while he saw it as an opportunity to redeem himself and prove to me that he was trying to change.
…
Back to the now.
As our call continued last night, he suggested that, “the answer is at least not a ‘no’,” to which I responded for him to repeat the question. He said it was whether or not I would be “his monogamous companion.” After a few barbs back and forth I finally said that there was something I had wanted to say to him. (Where did this courage come from?)
I was miserable. I mean, seriously, I had no intention in the least of saying any of what I said at that time. I was about to go out with my friends! I was supposed to be having a great time! It was my friggin’ birthday weekend and I did not want this to happen - not this way, not now. But I said it:
… I get the feeling that you are far more into me than I am with you
… I feel like you are more serious about me than I am about you
… I am really torn about saying anything to you because from one minute to the next I feel one way then the other about you; I love hanging out with you and having a good conversation… but
… I just haven’t been feeling that, erm, romantic ’spark’; I think we’re good for friends but…
As I heard his responses, each time, I tried to back out of the hole I had just dug for myself. Seriously, he really did take it “as well as could be expected” in that he said that he honestly appreciates being told the truth rather than be strung along, etc. We even continued to talk a bit more as I tried to help him understand what all I meant by what I said.
I was hurting, badly. You see, he is on the verge of a huge change in his life, one that I truly, in my heart, want to be witness to. He used to cycle competitively and is awaiting receipt of his new custom-built bike. He will pour his heart and soul into getting back on his bike and starting to ride competitively again. Whenever he talks about this, I see the passion in his eyes and I am astounded. I know he will be a different and better man for it and this is one huge reason I wanted to see our relationship out for a while longer. I told him as much, last night, as I was breaking his heart.
As I was breaking my own heart.
What hurts the most right now is knowing that he was really has been trying to change. On Friday night he wanted to treat me to something for my birthday, so we hung out at a restaurant and talked while he ate (I had dinner earlier with my parents) and we had some drinks. He had just bought a new car that afternoon and was quite proud of it and had me drive it to and from the restaurant (a huge sign of trust). While we were driving he’d occasionally put his hand on mine - something he had never done before. Later, when I was getting into my car to leave, he put his arms around my neck and leaned his forehead against mine and told me about what a nice time he had with me, etc. And all I could do was stand there, being almost aloof and nodding along.
Why did I have to say anything last night? Right when he was putting himself on the line… finally opening up to me like I wanted him to for so long? Am I fickle? I mean, I got exactly what I wanted from him: desire, interest, loyalty. And then I throw it back as if it’s just not good enough for me.
…
About eighty-percent of the time, I feel like I’m certain in my feelings that this was never going to be a long-term relationship. In fact, I had resolved myself some time ago - at least to a degree - that he wasn’t “the one.” However, I then turn around on myself thinking, “You’re just putting up your own wall… you yourself are scared to ‘be’ with anyone.” That’s how I feel right now: like things were starting to get serious and I got scared and ran away. And I hate giving up on anything I’ve put effort into, I really and honestly do. It feels like such a waste of resources… of energy… of time… of myself.
What if he was the one? What if he’s the only guy who will every take me for who I am: body and mind alike. He made me feel beautiful: something no one has ever made me feel in my life (I mean that). He wants to be around me, spend time with me, and get to know me. And I tossed it aside…
Was Joni Mitchell right when she said, “you don’t know what you got till its gone?”